Row concave Shape Decorative svg added to bottom

Selling Your House: Fix It, Stage It, or Lower the Price?

If you’re getting ready to sell your home, you’ve probably wondered whether you should fix it, stage it, or lower the price. We hear this question from sellers all the time here in Grand Rapids and across West Michigan.

Here’s our big tip: you only get one chance to make a first impression. We have seen this play out time and time again, and it shapes how we prepare every home for the market.

Quick Answer: Should You Fix, Stage, or Lower the Price?

Fix and stage your home before you list it. When your home hits the market, the first wave of buyers sees it right away. Improvements and staging matter before we ever talk about price. Listing a home as is and dropping the price later will cost you more money than fixing it up and staging it before you list.

Why the Order Matters When Selling Your Home

Many sellers do this backwards, so here is how it typically goes:

  1. You list the home as is, and it doesn’t look its best.
  2. Thirty days go by, and it hasn’t sold.
  3. You start thinking, “Maybe we should fix it up. Maybe we should stage it.”

By then, you’ve already missed the mark. That first wave of buyers has been through the house. They know it hasn’t sold, and they don’t feel great about it. We can pretty much guarantee that listing it as is and dropping the price will cost you more than fixing it up and staging it before you list.

Real Example: A $25,000 Investment in a Grand Rapids Home

About a year ago, a couple reached out to us. They built their home 30 years ago, were the original owners, and raised their family there. It was a big house of about 4,000 square feet, and like many homes of that age, it didn’t have all of the updates. It still had:

  • Original carpet
  • Oak trim everywhere
  • Oak cabinets
  • Gold light fixtures throughout

It was dated. If they had done nothing, we would have been looking at a list price of around $650,000.

These clients told us they had six months and wanted to do this the right way. They had time, a place to go temporarily, and the resources. They were willing to follow our recommendations as long as they were within reason and would earn a return on their investment.

The Plan

We brought in our stager and our designer to build a plan. Based on the stager’s recommendations, the clients were comfortable investing about $25,000. Here is what we did:

  • Pulled out the original carpet
  • Refinished the hardwood floors
  • Painted all of the oak trim throughout the entire house
  • Swapped out every gold light fixture

We stayed right on budget at around $25,000.

The Results

We listed the home at $725,000. It showed incredibly well, and buyers responded right away. We received six offers, and the home sold for $800,000.

That means a $25,000 investment took the home from an estimated $650,000 list price to an $800,000 sale price. The clients were absolutely ecstatic. They followed the plan, made the right decisions, and made another six figures by following directions.

Why We Include a Designer and Stager in Our Services

This is exactly why we include an interior designer and stager as part of our services. We feel they are critical. Our goal is to make our clients as much money as we can, based on the investment they are comfortable with.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I fix up my house before selling?

Yes. Improvements and staging matter before we ever talk about price, because the first wave of buyers is the group that sees your home at its best chance to impress.

Is it better to lower the price or stage a home?

Based on our experience, listing a home as is and dropping the price costs more than fixing it up and staging it before you list.

What happens if I list my home as is and wait to make improvements?

If your home sits for 30 days, the first wave of buyers has already seen it. They know it hasn’t sold, and they don’t feel great about it, so you’ve already missed the mark with them.

How much should I spend to get my home ready to sell?

It depends on your home and your comfort level. In the example above, the stager’s recommendations led to a $25,000 investment, and the home sold for $800,000 after six offers. Our goal is to maximize what you make based on the investment you are comfortable with.

What updates helped sell the 4,000-square-foot home in this example?

We removed the original carpet, refinished the hardwood floors, painted all the oak trim, and replaced every gold light fixture.

Thinking About Selling in Grand Rapids?

If you’re thinking about selling in Grand Rapids or West Michigan and want to know what your home is worth, we are happy to help. Reach out to the team at May Group Realtors at RE/MAX of Grand Rapids. We’d love to chat.